This started off innocently enough. The odd baggage scanner at a few select metro stations (I only saw it myself at Zhongshan Park). Now, it’s been implemented at every station in the city, all in the name of Expo 2010.
To enter a turnstyle at any station now, if you have any baggage you must pass it through an airport-like conveyor belt to be scanned and inspected. On the other side are security staff staring at a couple of monitors.
I didn’t mind this at first, but it’s grown to really irritate me. I take the metro to work every day, so twice a day I have to pass my laptop bag through this stupid machine, wait for it to come out the other end, and have the strap get caught on the other side.
To add to the fun, people in Shanghai are not exactly known for being orderly or waiting their turn in line. During rush hour, you often have to fight to get your bag in, and then rush to the other side to grab it through the crowd of people waiting for theirs. If you have groceries, expect a few items to roll out of the bag before the end of its conveyor belt journey.
When you take into account that the personnel are often not paying attention, some machines are (or at least were) apparently not staffed or even turned on between 6 – 7 AM, and couriers still hand deliver packages over the railings to their counterparts waiting in the station, this is security theatre at its worst and it rivals anything the west has to offer.
I’m hoping that this whole thing will be over when the Expo is, but something tells me the city didn’t spend a fortune to put scanners in over 200 metro stations with the word ‘temporary’ in mind. We’re still taking our shoes off at airports in North America, still unable to bring a few ounces of liquid into a departure area, and the “terror alert level” will never be green. Once implemented and publicly accepted, security measures like these rarely get reversed.
The only upside is that all the security staff I’ve encountered have been very friendly, and none of them had the self-inflated sense of importance/authority that rent-a-cops and TSA staff in the west have. To be fair, as one anonymous security staff member allegedly posted online recently, it’s not exactly fun for them either.